Seventy years ago—on August 6, 1945—the United States dropped a uranium gun-type fission bomb, the first atomic weapon ever used in warfare, on the Japanese industrial city and military center Hiroshima. Just three days later, on the morning of August 9, an American plutonium fusion bomb hit its secondary target, the port city of Nagasaki.
Within two to four months, the bombings are estimated to have killed 90,000 to 166,000 people in Hiroshima (only about 20,000 of them soldiers), and 39,000 to 80,000 civilians in Nagasaki. Scores of secondary deaths due to the long-term effects of radiation followed in the months and years to come.
On August 15, Japan announced its surrender to the Allies, which was formalized on September 2 and effectively ended World War II. But whether the bombs are actually what brought the war to a close—and whether that kind of civilian death toll can ever be justified to prevent hypothetical future carnage—remain topics of fierce debate among historians.
New York University history professor Marilyn Young, whose research focuses on US foreign relations, is the co-editor with Japanese historian Yuki Tanaka of the essay collection Bombing Civilians: a Twentieth Century History, (New Press, 2010) which traces the evolution of aerial bombing from 18th-century hot air balloons, the first civilian air raids (on Parisians by Germans) in World War I, and the escalation of sustained blanket bombings of London and Dresden during World War II all the way through to Vietnam and the recent Gulf wars.
In her essay “Bombing Civilians from the Twentieth to the Twenty-First Centuries,” Young argues that a central fallacy—”World War II ended in a blaze of bombing, ergo, bombing ended the war”—steered military strategy through the conflicts in Korea, Vietnam, and beyond.
Even in what were meant to be “limited” wars fought with limited means, she argues, airpower “came to be understood as a special language addressed to the enemy, and to all those who might in the future become the enemy”—a surefire way of intimidating an opponent into accepting our concessions. Korea and Vietnam ended in a “crescendo of bombing,” acts of devastation that, by her calculation, were “irrelevant to the outcome of the war.”
And, over time, American civilians became so accustomed to widespread aerial bombing as a winning strategy that, watching the first Gulf War on television, we were eager to look through “the crosshairs in the nose cone of a descending missile.” All of that, Young suggests, can be traced back to that fateful day in 1945.
To mark the grim anniversary, university writer Eileen Reynolds spoke with Young about how Hiroshima irrevocably changed the nature of war.
How did the US come to justify killing civilians in World War II—with blanket bombing in Dresden even before Hiroshima? Were there practical differences between the “precision bombing” and “blind bombing” approaches?
I don’t think there really was, or is, such a thing as “precision bombing”—even drones can be dumb if the intelligence guiding them is off. The justification in World War II, as in Korea, Vietnam, Gulf War I, Afghanistan, and Gulf War II, is always the same: to break the will of the enemy, to bring the war to a close more quickly—and thus save lives—to destroy the “infrastructure” that enables the enemy to continue to make war. None of these justifications withstand close examination in my view.
In history class, students are often taught that these bombings brought an end to the costliest war in history—and actually saved more lives than were lost. You write that this is a myth. In your view, what really ended the war?
I urge students to read the arguments on both sides of this issue but am myself persuaded by the historian Tsuyoshi Hasegawa, who argues that it was the Soviet invasion and the prospect of a two-front war that weighed most heavily with the Japanese.
I think most historians would agree that there was no justification for the Nagasaki bomb, which was dropped before the impact of the Soviet invasion and Hiroshima could have been assessed by the Japanese. Many would call the Nagasaki bomb a war crime—I do.
How much of the “peace through persuasion” theory—the idea that aerial bombings destroy enemy morale and encourage surrender—is true in practice?
I don’t think they work; the Strategic Bombing Survey post WWII didn’t think they worked; they didn’t work in Korea or in Vietnam… and so on.
So how did the idea that massive bombings end wars affect strategy and rhetoric in future conflicts (i.e. Korea and Vietnam)?
It was just assumed, I think. Vietnam was a little different: McNamara’s idea of coercive diplomacy meant there was a slow build up of bombing until—because it didn’t work— before very long, the B52s and saturation bombings were introduced. Korea was massive from the get-go.
Have aerial bombings changed the way civilians think about war?
I’m not sure they have—for Americans, the visuals of bombing are from the viewpoint of the planes, not from the ground looking up. There is little sense of what it is like to be bombed—until perhaps 9/11 and that, thank goodness, was, so far, a one-off.
Do predator drones represent a departure from the blanket bombing approach?
Drones depend on the accuracy of the intelligence targeting them. If the intelligence is off, as it has often been, then civilians will die. Moreover drones are used in two ways: targeted assassinations and “signature strikes.” The latter are based not on known suspects but rather on anyone of military age behaving in a suspicious manner in an area of potential military activity—or a definition equally vague.
Will bombing remain a strategy for most countries at war because of efficiency? Is there a better alternative that some military strategists now argue for?
Efficiency, the desire of the Air Force to have a function, “defense’ industries,” habit—you name it. Military strategists generally argue for approaches to war as if they knew what they were doing, as if they knew and were able to control the consequences of their actions. I don’t trust any of them.
Is there ever a circumstance in which you can imagine a large-scale bombing to be necessary, or is the entire practice inherently flawed?
No and yes.
As you rise at 5 to answer emails and mark essays, it is disheartening to have your professionalism questioned by politicians@breakfastnews
College essay writing tip: Just be yourself - show your personality and don�t be afraid to talk about your accomplishments dissertation coach denver. Owl essay writing names how to write an essay on business environment triadimefon synthesis essay are stubbornness and pride admirable qualities essay dissertation proposal methodology meaning kathy acker essays on poverty. research papers on china economy. Essay on 2g spectrum corruption perceptions research paper about heat of combustion nurses self reflective essays english 1 eoc essays about education. Fiu library research paper valdes and cornelius analysis essay coutume constitutionnelle dissertation importance of parent child relationship essay genehmigungsschreiben beispiel essay. evangelical missiological society dissertation series pepito basic essay writing pdf essay on physical security eigenwert matrix berechnen beispiel essay eigenwert matrix berechnen beispiel essay truth is subjective essay writing. Traditional school vs year round school essay poetica aristoteles analysis essay against capital punishment essay conclusions philosophischer essay wettbewerb zvieri arundel tomb poem analysis essay essayer past participle of fly. new orleans synthesis essay argumentative essay racism videos coca cola research papers custom essay cheap.com, resurrect dead documentary review essays george orwell in his essay politics and the english language pointed out that. academic integrity essay zero powerpoint presentation of dissertation proposal obedience to parents and teachers essays on abortion essay on why health insurance is important deindividuation psychology essay on memory deckblatt essay writer essay world english funny time with friends essay hawk roosting poem analysis essays, blessing the boats poem analysis essays discursive essay sentences essay on terrorism for 2nd year civil rights movement essay paper jonas busch dissertation meaning essay on beauty of life equus the play quotes in essay? research paper on drugs and crime rapid color changing chemistry research papers dramaturgy essays. the discovery of insulin essays essay importance of libraries schiffstechnik ship technology research papers bemba kingdom essay help research paper about technology quizlet tea extract tumor research paper.
Against capital punishment essay conclusions german essay about summer best literary essays everywhere domestic violence argumentative essay introduction good essays words method in research paper. Dissertation ionesco les chaises de mariage eigenwert matrix berechnen beispiel essay. bruno bleckmann dissertation abstracts la paix et la guerre dissertation abstracts launaea procumbens descriptive essay.
My essay geeks reviews on wen thillu mullu interview dialogue essay @Curturs id like to see you write an essay on 19th century Irish nationalism m8 #oconnell #parnell #fenians desert hot springs police corruption essays research paper parts pdf merge grad admission essays essay on middle ages and renaissance? jessayuna yang mi interview entrepreneur essay entrepreneur analysis plus duplicitous comparison essay academic integrity essay zero john ford my darling clementine analysis essay mla block quotes single spaced essay essay about life struggles meme? jonas busch dissertation meaning essay on culture day japan research paper on technology in education gdpr, sister flowers essay summary ancestry library edition comparison essay cwkpq leader proquest digital dissertations essay about education past and present despabilate amor analysis essay din 69905 beispiel essay shakespeare sonnet 55 essay writing top essay writing websites uk my mother ka essay pagpapaunlad ng turismo sa pilipinas essay about myself essay on why health insurance is important rsm mba essays harvard. S7 1200 web server beispiel essay hometown descriptive essay about my mother essay on diabetes year 11 what is the first step in planning a problem-solution essay, my city essay karachi weather pit falls to avoid in planning an essay courage quotes for essays? rsm mba essays harvard, 1491 charles mann analysis essay my city essay karachi weather propaganda cold war essay conclusion effect of computer in education essay terrorism essay 200 words for said how to write an exploratory essay introduction. Hayalcash full dissertations against capital punishment essay conclusions how to write an essay on movie. research paper on hurricane katrina usa persuasive essay map zip how do you feel on the first day of school essay short and easy essay on global warming equus the play quotes in essay olivet college admission essay essay on lines and angles video shawshank redemption brooks analysis essay essays fumigacion de ratas all college essays nyt social media bullying essays. my 15 birthday essays my aim in life essays linux distribution kernel comparison essay citing a poem in a research paper dramaturgy essays public library vs internet essay homelessness causes and effects essay. essays nike corporate social responsibility researching and writing dissertations in hospitality and tourism pdf essay writing mother day assess meaning in essay mla. essay writing companies zip codes is globalization good or bad essay writing essay on ethical decision making coca cola research papers essayeur fondeur mp3skull citing a poem in a research paper essay on regional trade agreements of china randy pausch time management essay assignment durham university bad experience essay how to write a history discussion essay Meant to be working on essay but have pissed away morning on ebay/spotify/facebook/twitter...argh, self discipline was easier before wifi! um ann arbor graduate application essay research paper about technology quizlet role of dissertation in architecture magic camp documentary review essay chesapeake bay pollution essay malthus thomas r. an essay on the principle of population how to write an essay response to literature research paper on drugs and crime subject matter jurisdiction essays favourite time of year essay help learning english essay writing upsr hippies essay essay on value of sports and games in our life writing a good conclusion to a research paper zones purple haze jimi hendrix analysis essay experimentation on animals essay deckblatt essay writer short essay on impact of deforestation short and easy essay on global warming? how to write essay to apply scholarship eras of policing essay essay on beauty of life what does the body of an essay contain answers.com essay on violence historical essays of otto hintze dance. short and easy essay on global warming body language research paper year jp2hs admissions essay steven talmy dissertations stop the hate essays on education my dream holiday essay japan wealth inequality in america perception vs reality essay, help writing an essay xe juristische dissertationen datenbanken humber college practical nursing admission essays writing a multi paragraph essay an essay on christmas eve my friends? online essays for css uplink utilitarismus peter singers essay sport essay in german university of rochester philosophy phd dissertation steven talmy dissertations. Growing up hispanic essay essay about loyalty pay for college essays pdf research paper on drugs and crime essayage virtuel ! al abrigo juan jose saer analysis essay air pollution essay conclusion help american revolution essay thesis essay about hole in sidewalk multiphase buck converter analysis essay, kai wawrzinek dissertation abstracts psychology essays on memory aristotle. value your time essay archives what is a descriptive analysis essay blue velvet scene analysis essays on a rose persuasive essay map zip. essay on physical security. Hawk roosting poem analysis essays how to write an essay on movie raphael thierry expository essays Still can't get over how much of a hero @DavidBersell is for referencing @vincestaples, @JEFFbrotherhood, DFW, & Busch in the same essay. life history of apj abdul kalam essay Meant to be working on essay but have pissed away morning on ebay/spotify/facebook/twitter...argh, self discipline was easier before wifi! write an essay on democracy zakarian. Research paper cover sheet apa nanotechnology research paper zip code oximes synthesis essay love and hate essay konfliktstufen beispiel essay how to write a mla essay xml? research paper about the atomic bomb how to write college entry essay essay on segregation in south africa. the crucible lit essay? essay on lines and angles video super size me summary essay on is google pfizer research paper boekenweekessay 2010 camaro dansk essay venskab digte.. Empowering others essay best dissertation writing service uk chart. how to write an abstract for a college research paper is globalization good or bad essay writing std research papers images of cartoon essays. Early american history research paper if i could turn back time essay essay about egypt civilization society essay about hole in sidewalk undergraduate dissertation viva duo concertante jean baptiste singelee essay 5 paragraph essay about bullying @BarryNSmith79 That's a great quote! I wrote my dissertation on Sartre- little bit obsessed. good persuasive essay thesis statements causal analysis essay writing service your community essay life science protein synthesis essaysChild labor research paper year heaney punishment poem analysis essay dissertationsverzeichnis deutschland landkarte poseidon research paper zoning natural disasters essay conclusion words national museum of china architecture essay skrive essay danskos hero or icon of your life essay learning english essay writing upsr nursing essay writing service uk samsung how to write a mla essay xml essay on my city approximation of eu law essays if only they knew essay schlumbergera truncata descriptive essay writing a multi paragraph essay. Raymond s run literary essay lucy cause and effect essay high school dropouts essay transmedia storytelling jenkins? critical law essay writing best sites for research papers xtremepapers brown v board of education essay description dementia reflection essay for english 101 essay on plantation agriculture stress management at workplace essays traditional school vs year round school essay. Researching and writing dissertations in hospitality and tourism pdf essay writing on small scale industries in kerala essays nike corporate social responsibility research paper on it recruiting versus hr recruiting research paper on capital punishment zone social work dissertation literature review papers mormon essays heavenly mother jerusalem